Sunday, July 12, 2009

Separate But Not Equal

A few months into knowing M, we began to socialize with his friends. He'd come to that particular school in part because there was a Pakistani professor who was working hard to import as many students from Pakistan as he could. As a result, his school had a pretty large population of Pakistani students for him to socialize with.

The first ever dinner invitation we received as a couple had been from The Maulana - the most religious, longest bearded, always shalwar-kameezed guy. He was so kind. He made so much food and even though I was the only female in attendance, he made sure I felt comfortable and enjoyed the food. (He never once made eye contact with me, though.)

After falling into a pattern of joining M in his social visits with that and other Pakistani friends, I began to feel more comfortable. Then, one day, we were invited to a dinner that was to be a large dinner party - almost all of the Pakistani students and their families (as a few were married as well.) I thought nothing of it - I'd been to a few Pakistani student dinner parties already, I'd had a nice time, this would be no different. I was wrong.

When we got there, a few people had already arrived. There were several men there that I'd never met, and I wasn't introduced to. Soon after The Maulana also arrived, and M told me that the men were going to join together in a congregational evening prayer, and that dinner would be served afterward. One of the women there - a wife of a grad student - signaled for me to come into the other room (a bedroom). Inside there were two other wives of grad students (one was also a graduate student herself.) I had thought I would wait somewhere while they also made their evening prayer, but none of the women prayed. Instead we all sat on the bed. 

It was an uncomfortable silence most of the time. The three wives were all very different. One was from India, had only been in America a few months, and barely spoke to me all night. Another was Pakistani and had known my husband back in Pakistan as well and spoke to me more than the first, but still not that much. The third (the graduate student) was the only woman besides me to wear jeans. She spoke the most to me, asking me not only the usual questions about how much I knew about Pakistani culture or whether I could cook, but also fairly atypical (in my experience, anyway) questions about my own American life and my studies.

Eventually we'd been in the room for a long time. I had seen prayers performed before, and I knew they didn't last that long. I wondered when we'd all get back in the same room and start the party already! Just then, one of their husbands came to the room and told us to come eat. I was so relieved to be out of that cramped room where I'd been set aside for the past 20 minutes. I was so relieved I'd be back with my M instead of having to make forced small talk with these strangers who I thought I had so little in common with! 

But I was not going to be reunited with M. What I saw when I walked out of the room was that all the men had already filled their plates with food and arranged themselves in a circle on the floor around a large sheet serving as a kind of floor tablecloth. They had already begun eating without us. Even my M. There was no room in the circle for anyone else. The women were to eat at the dining table in the next room.

So I ate. I didn't even look over at M. I was pissed off. What was he thinking? Why would he think I wanted to spend my whole evening with these other women instead of him? Why was he allowing this? Why didn't he come and rescue me, take me with him to the "Men's section" or just leave alltogether? The more time that passed, the more upset I got. After eating we women again went into the bedroom and again made as much forced small talk as we could. 

At one point M did come to the doorway of the room, smile on his face, and asked how I was doing. I was so upset at that point I couldn't speak, so I just did a curt head nod. What else could I have said, anyway? "Why the hell have you left me to rot in here with these people I don't know?" I think he must have known there was more to my head nod, though, because not long thereafter he came back to retrieve me from the this room, asking if I was ready to leave. I was ready all right. 

We left, got in the car, and started driving away. It took me sometime before I could compose myself enough to speak. When I did I was all accusation and confrontation. How could he leave me like that? What did he think he was doing? Who the hell leaves their girlfriend in the company of strangers for hours? What was up with this boy's club business? It was a very heated tirade. 

Eventually he calmed me down with protestations of apology, carelessness and thoughtlessness as well as promises that it would never happen again. He asked how my evening had been and I told him exactly what I thought about having dinner holed up in a room with three women, two of whom I had never previously met and one I knew only superficially. I told him just what I thought he could do with his segregated dinner parties. 

Unfortunately, the gender segregation did not end that day.

18 comments:

Huda said...

Hmm, this happens all the time in our culture. Men always eat first and separately. I can imagine what you went through. :)

ellen557 said...

Argh I remember my first one of those... except I didn't see Mo at all.
What sticks out is three women chatting away to each other in Arabic, basically ignoring me and then sitting around me. I guess that was the time they thought they might want to include me so they asked "Do you want to ask us any questions?"

:|

Faiqa said...

Your story, though not funny, reminds me of something my mom and FIL both say... "In *this* house, the women eat FIRST." Both of them come from families where the women are very strong.

We segregate a little in our desi gatherings, but not as strictly as you've mentioned. It's more organic... the women sit in the family room & men in the living room. We even joke when one of the men comes by to say hi and say something like, "UGH, what do *you* want?! Can't we have a little peace?" But it's all in good fun.

Men and women wander over to each other's sides frequently. I just don't think I could socialize with a group as stringent as you've described, though I respect their choices.

Interestingly, most of my friends who were raised/brought up here are more segregated than *my* parents and their friends were, despite the fact that my parents are faily conservative. I remember my parents sitting with ALL of their friends in the living room together.

To each their own, right? As long as your not obligated to engage in that interaction on a regular basis...

Sorry so long, as usual, I had more to say than I thought.

Faiqa said...

ugh. "as long as YOU'RE not" ... not "your not"

Stephanie said...

Salam Alaikum--Interestingly I just went to a bangledeshi party the other day that was the exact same thing! I'm used to segregating men and women and normally don't mind, even prefer it in larger groups. This time though I was ushered off into a bedroom with 3 or 4 women I didn't know and several of our children. They were nice enough but it's always awkward making small talk to complete strangers. They even set up a little buffet on the dresser so I relished in the food and smiled and cooed at the children alot.

nadia said...

Like yourself, I used to feel awkward being segregated in a room with strangers, but I think I've learned how to make small talk. With desi women, I think you can ask any type of questions, personal ones even. I don't think most of them mind.

Coffee Catholic said...

For pity sake! They didn't even have a room with a sofa and some basic creature comforts? You just got stuffed in a bedroom and expected to sit there on a bed without tea or anything?

People treat their pet dogs better!!

Anonymous said...

Yes, I remember those days quite vividly...lol. I too was shocked at first....well, especially since my husband never set me aside to explain or let me know about it.

It's not so bad though...just keep an open mind and you must have an extreme sense of humor. Remember, "when life throws you lemons...make lemonade!"

luckyfatima said...

I have had similar experiences. A lot of families i know are more westernized and insist that the women eat first though.

my IL's family and the extended khaandaan do not practice gender segregation at their gatherings though.

i think it is okay for singles but in a large social functioning, families should be able to sit together.

depending on who the crowd is, I have also spent those evenings on the bed playing with those ladies kids cuz it is hard to talk to them.

Crysmissmichelle said...

I agree with LF, when it's a family gathering you should be able to sit together. . .I usually avoid these situations as much as possible. I had my first really segregated one recently and went with full knowledge and only as a 'favor' to M. . .the women avoided me like the plague, even in Hijab. . .and even the female servers (buffet line with people serving up the food) treated me like crap. . .but they still didn't stuff me in a bedroom for 20 minutes. o u c h.

Gori Girl said...

I'll admit that I've never had this experience, but, then, my husband knows exactly what would happen if he tried. Also, his family is pretty liberal, as are all of our South Asian friends.

lufarah said...

As I played no part in planning my wedding celebrations, I was in shock when i found it was a gender segregated party. Took me a couple years to get over it.

aka_Mariha said...

You have to always remember that those men were raised very differently. While your husband obviously has a different mindset, the other men in the room don't. The moment you're brought in with the rest of them (as you mentioned you would have liked), is the moment they lose respect for you and your husband. ALWAYS have trust in your husband with these things. He's only protecting your respect with others in the culture. Sometimes he probably doesn't realize the need to explain everything. I've learned to stop getting ticked off just like you did and carry on with the women. Desi's are always impressed when a Gori can assimilate in their lifestyle happily (or at least appear to). Next time just keep your chin up, smile, converse kindly with the women, and remember that your husband loves you and is doing what he knows is best!

pi said...

i am desi and muslim and this segregation thing really bothers me too. i feel many a times i have nothing in common with the women who can't talk about anything else but jewelery and kids. (Which both are okay to talk about but there are so many other things in life to talk about)

Katherine said...

Ah, the memories... When I found myself in this situation, at least we also prayed. All the women spoke Urdu to each other and some wouldn't even return my salaam. The high point was when one auntie did talk to me... To tell me my husband would be miserable but I could come to her for advice on "our men."

I preferred dinner parties in Pakistan. The sisters would engage me in positive conversation and try to make me feel welcome. We'd end up drawing mendhi flowers on each others' hands. Success! It's not that hard to be nice, is it?

Aynur said...

Yeah the first times I went to segregated events like the one you mentioned (my hubby is Turkish) I was really uncomfortable. Now I just suck it up, I really don't have a choice. I just figure I'm going to be bored out of my mind for the night (or few hours, whatever).

Mark said...

This isn't a desi thing at all, its a muslim thing.

To me your story sounds incredibly odd. I'm indian catholic, and have never experienced anything like this at all. At desi party's with hindu friends as well. Everyone drinks, socilises and eats with whoever.

Gender segregation sounds like an absolute nightmare!

Anonymous said...

Mark is right - this is a Muslim thing. It's also most common with the more rural, lower-socio-economic populations. Whether you want to implicitly endorse your own segregation and subjugation for your gender - or refuse to do so - is definitely an individual opinion. But this kind of treatment of one's closest partner and supporter in inhumane and immoral and it's easy to find one in a lose-lose situation around people who endorse it. Can you simply not go to these "parties"? Or are there more evolved groups that your husband and you might befriend and spend time with?